An essay argues civilisation should have frozen around 2003: technology was useful but not dominant, people were not permanently online, and physical life was still the default.

Ask which dynasty you would time-travel to and any sane person picks the present. Someone has flipped the question: should technology have stopped in the early 2000s and gone no further?
Before 29 June 2007
The essay pins the date: before the iPhone launched, ideally around 2003. A feature phone called, texted, ran Snake and loaded simple web pages — enough for communication, not enough for much else. The camera was poor, but the photos were viewable.
Crucially, it was not smart enough to make you look down at the screen every thirty seconds. Social life still meant people interacting with people, not people interacting with machines. Wanted to talk? You phoned. Wanted to meet someone? You went to see them.
Offline was still an option
Back then you could simply not go online and life carried on fine. Chatting, dating, shopping, entertainment, maps — all concrete things. Now each is an app, and everything starts with opening the right one.
Technology used to be a tool, not a way of life. Today you cannot be offline; most of life has moved onto the screen.
The author's position is blunt: technology must stay in balance with people, the early 2000s were that balance point, and everything since has put tech in charge with humans as appendages. Ruan Yifeng does not fully agree, but he grants that the slowness and the inconvenience have something worth missing.
As for AI, it has made most human skills worthless — one hopes it takes us somewhere better.
Why it matters
The nostalgia here is not an argument against technology but a question about what it costs. Every gain in convenience is paid for somewhere, and the essay turns the low-grade daily friction — the constant glancing at phones, the app for everything, offline life becoming a luxury — into a position you can argue with rather than just grumble about.



Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.