Daily Picks
← Back
TechPluralisticCory Doctorow2026-11-18

Banks trained us to be easy marks, then scammers moved inPluralistic: Enshittifiers groom us for scammers (18 Nov 2026)

Banks, employers and insurers have spent years forcing customers through chaotic, ever-changing security rituals, which leaves the field wide open for fraudsters.

You wake up to a call from your bank asking you to verify a transaction, then a text telling you to install a new app for two-factor authentication. You curse, then you do it.

That is exactly the problem: **once official institutions are as chaotic as a scam, a fraudster no longer has to convince you, only to imitate the chaos.**

What 'normal' now looks like

You log in to a service you use daily and face a CAPTCHA unlike any you have seen, a redirect to a third-party site to take selfies and upload ID documents, or a demand to switch off your browser's advanced privacy protections.

Nobody uses the random passwords from their password manager anymore; they just click whatever link arrives by text or email. Fraud-prevention contractors call from outsourcing firms that cannot pronounce your bank's name.

The author is a case in point: nearly 20 years with a UK bank left them holding a customer number, a telephone passcode, eight password-recovery answers, a web username, a web password, a digital secure key password and a PIN.

Then the bank upgraded its systems and blocked the secure open-source Android fork on their phone, on the grounds that 'open source is considered insecure.' They have not been able to log in for two months.

The fraudster only has to look more legitimate than you're used to

Tech-savvy people are often easier to fool. The more you know, the more you have seen the official system behave incoherently, and the less surprised you are when something obviously insecure is demanded of you.

One editor nearly got phished buying a train ticket because years of dealing with giant companies' creaking websites had taught them to expect weirdness. Their phrase for it: expected incompetence enables fraud.

The effort against fraud belongs with the institutions, not with the public's ability to spot it.

My take

The confidence that you could never be scammed is precisely the customer profile fraudsters love. Shifting the burden onto users lets scammers ride the institutions' mess all the way to the bank.

Why it matters

The default anti-fraud playbook tells users to be more vigilant, but the world they face is not a sane system with occasional glitches — it is a daily routine of anomalies. Demanding that ordinary people develop a sixth sense is worse than demanding that institutions make their processes stable, predictable and staffed by someone you can actually reach.

Share to
Read the originalPluralisticPluralistic: Enshittifiers groom us for scammers (18 Nov 2026)

You might also read

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.

Daily Picks

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.