Daily Picks
← Back
InvestingOf Dollars And DataNick Maggiulli2026-09-15

The best portfolio of the past 50 years was 36% your own houseWhat Was the Best Portfolio Over the Last 50 Years?

An optimal portfolio is only the perfect answer to a stretch of history that is already over, so the real optimum is whatever you can hold without switching.

The author compared US stocks, international stocks, REITs, corporate bonds, 10-year Treasuries, 3-month T-bills, gold, commodities and US homes over 1972 to 2025, looking for the mix with the highest return per unit of risk.

Every champion comes with a catch

Gold was the flashiest: it posted the top return in 13 of 54 years, roughly once every four. It was also the wildest, up 106% in 1979 and down 37.6% in 1981, with annual volatility of 24.7%, the highest in the group.

One dollar put into the S&P 500 in 1972 was worth 35.90 in real terms by 2025, far ahead of gold at 12.89, REITs at 12.26 and international stocks at 11.27.

Commodities were the worst, turning a dollar into 0.42 while still swinging 14% a year — no growth and plenty of noise, which is why the author avoids them.

The optimum is a third house

On a risk-adjusted basis the optimal mix is 36% US homes, 27% S&P 500, 18% gold, 16% 10-year Treasuries and 3% REITs.

Homes earn that weight because they are rarely repriced, so they look calm on paper while still delivering. Their worst drawdown was about 13%, against 48% for the S&P 500.

Housing also comes with leverage nothing else offers: a 30-year fixed mortgage cannot be margin called. The median American homeowner holds 51% of net worth in their home, so many households are already running a soft version of this portfolio.

Change the dates and the answer changes

Solve using only 1972 to 1998 and the optimum becomes 68% S&P 500, 24% gold, 6% international stocks and 2% corporate bonds. The 36% in housing vanishes entirely.

Portfolio optimisation, the author says, is a cruel art: you get the perfect solution to a problem that no longer exists. You can only ever compute it backwards.

Which leaves the plain conclusion — the best portfolio is the one you never have to switch.

Share to
Read the originalOf Dollars And DataWhat Was the Best Portfolio Over the Last 50 Years?

You might also read

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.

Daily Picks

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.