Daily Picks
← Back
Society & IdeasAfter BabelCarmen Lim2026-09-17

Test scores have fallen for a decade — the phone is a fair suspectAre Phone-Free Schools Working?

PISA results keep sliding across countries, and the evidence from school phone bans suggests they help high-schoolers, slowly and in more ways than test scores alone.

PISA tests 15-year-olds worldwide every three years, and the 2025 results are the worst on record for OECD countries. Maths, reading and science all fell. COVID closures cannot explain the whole story: in many countries scores started dropping years earlier, and after the pandemic years they did not rebound — they did not even slow down.

The timing lines up with phones

The decline began around the mid-2010s, exactly when smartphones became ubiquitous among teenagers, schools adopted one laptop per child, and short-form video took over social media. The authors of the PISA report say so themselves: students read less for pleasure and have shifted to skim-reading feeds, which may be eroding their ability to handle long texts. And a device engineered to capture attention looks a poor match for sustained academic focus.

That leaves a narrower, answerable question: what happens when schools take the phones away? More than twenty US states and dozens of countries have done it, handing researchers a batch of natural experiments.

The headlines told half the story

A team at NYU Stern rounded up seven of these experiments. One study got most of the coverage, with the finding that bans have 'close to zero impact' on scores — but that number pools middle and high school together. High-schoolers used their phones two to three times as much; in high schools the ban did cut use, and maths scores rose a little, worth about one to two extra months of school. The problem is that the sample contained three times as many middle schools, which diluted the high-school effect.

Two other studies from the same period went largely unnoticed. In Norway, after a ban, fewer girls sought care for psychological symptoms, fewer reported being bullied, their grades improved and more went on to an academic track — with the biggest gains for girls from low-income families. In Rio de Janeiro, banning phones during class alone did almost nothing; only a full school-wide ban produced real gains in maths and Portuguese.

Look past the test scores

What schools actually wanted to change was the school day: less distraction, more face-to-face talk, less bullying, classrooms a teacher can manage. Two studies found disciplinary incidents rose in the first year, then fell back to baseline or lower by year two or three — an adjustment period, not a failed policy.

Future research should measure noise, playground activity, conversations, library checkouts and teacher burnout. And every study must first confirm that phone use actually dropped: if a policy is so poorly enforced that students keep scrolling, nothing else will improve.

In one line: phones are not the only reason scores are falling, but taking them out of the classroom is one of the few moves with visible results.

Share to
Read the originalAfter BabelAre Phone-Free Schools Working?

You might also read

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.

Daily Picks

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.