Noah Smith, long bullish on China's economy, has turned bearish for the first time. His main reason is not demography but AI: China's system is built for a manufacturing era that is ending.

Noah Smith says he was always a China bull, and that is exactly why he was a China hawk. Now, for the first time, he is bearish, and the biggest reason is not demographics but AI.
His argument is blunt: China's system is optimised to the extreme, but for an era that is coming to an end. It spends about 4% of GDP a year subsidising manufacturing in a bid to be the country that makes everything, yet export markets will saturate and domestic demand is weighed down by the property bust.
What I find more interesting is his self-correction: when he was bullish he wanted containment, and now that he is bearish he no longer feels the same urgency.



Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.