Daily Picks
← Back
Society & IdeasNoahpinionNoah Smith2026-09-09

Liberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration

Liberals must acknowledge that immigration is not a human right and craft a sustainable policy that benefits native citizens, or the far right will keep rising.

The far-right AfD's big win in Germany's Saxony-Anhalt has Europe on edge. The author argues this is not a post-pandemic backlash but voter anger over immigration.

Data shows a direct link between immigration and far-right voting. European countries are tightening policies, but the author fears these are tactical pauses that voters will see through.

Immigration is not a human right

Liberals must accept that migration is not a human right. We live in a world of sovereign states, and nations have the right to decide who enters. Laws must be upheld and enforced; undocumented immigrants are lawbreakers, not a protected identity.

Immigration should serve citizens

The purpose of immigration is to benefit existing citizens, economically and culturally. Liberals should revive arguments for immigration's benefits, select immigrants who contribute most, and reject the idea of immigration as colonial reparations.

The author argues this is the only sustainable liberal policy to permanently defuse anti-immigration sentiment and prevent the far right from returning.

Share to
Read the originalNoahpinionLiberalism needs a new philosophy of immigration

You might also read

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.

Daily Picks

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.