In an experiment, 350 people rated their own test scores and 1,750 advisers judged them; men guessed high, women said it was nothing, and only 31% of women were recommended a harder task.

Men got an average of 11 out of 20 right, women 10, yet men consistently guessed they had scored higher regardless of the real result. Seeing those self-assessments, advisers recommended 44% of the men and 31% of the women for a more ambitious task.
The sharpest turn comes later: once advisers were told that women tend to underpromote themselves and men to overpromote, the recommendations flipped, to 47% women and 37% men.
The author does not want the script flipped, and I think that would just be a different unfairness. A more practical fix might be anonymising the scoring, so the adviser sees the result and not the gender.



Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.