Daily Picks
← Back
Society & IdeasJSTOR DailyLivia Gershon2026-11-03

Cringe isn't about them, it's about your feelings being betrayedWhy We Cringe

English and women's studies scholar J. Logan Smilges argues that cringe is not just an emotion but a political one: it arises when you believed your feelings matched someone else's, and their behaviour says otherwise.

Your mom makes an off-colour remark about a server's makeup and you want to sink through the floor; a friend publicly declares their devotion to a show you find unbearable, and it happens again. Smilges calls cringing 'a physiological response to an affective crisis.'

The point isn't that the other person did something out of the ordinary. It's that they don't see it as out of the ordinary at all. We cringe because we assumed our feelings were in sync with theirs, and their behaviour tells us they aren't.

What stayed with me is the Office episode Smilges uses: the real cringe isn't the characters calling Kevin a 'dummy' or an 'idiot,' but Holly trying to defend him by calling him 'mentally challenged.' The scene's stance is that suspecting someone is disabled is a worse crime than throwing ableist insults at people you dislike.

Share to
Read the originalJSTOR DailyWhy We Cringe

You might also read

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.

Daily Picks

5 articles worth reading every day

Curated from high-quality sources, with concise summaries and key takeaways.